In a courtroom, there are usually two opposing sides: the prosecution and the defense. Each presents its version of the events, backed by evidence and arguments. The judge and jury must consider both sides before reaching a verdict. This process highlights the importance of hearing all perspectives before reaching a conclusion. Whether it is the courtroom or the situations of everyday life, it is always good to get all the information before reaching a conclusion.
Solomon provides us with wise instruction that encourages us to look at both sides of a story to arrive at the truth. Proverbs 18:17 states that the first person who comes to you with information may appear right. Using a courtroom allusion, Solomon goes on to say that everything could change when another comes and cross examines.
“The context here seems to be a judicial setting. This is the way things work in court. The prosecutor's "case" may seem strong ("right"), until the defense attorney has his say.”[1]
This is very practical as well because we have all received information about a person or situation. At first glance, the information may appear to be true and reliable. However, when we take time to look at the other side, we often find there is more to the story. Solomon’s wisdom is timeless because today we are inundated with information. Rather than naively believing the first thing we hear, we should carefully consider all the evidence.
“If someone comes to you with an evil report about someone else, don’t accept or pass it on until you have obeyed the test found in Deuteronomy 13:14. Make every effort to know if it is not slated, but totally true, certain and completely accurate.”[2]
Whether it is the courtroom or the situations of everyday life, it is always good to get all the information before reaching a conclusion. By doing so, we can save both ourselves and others from drawing the wrong conclusion or acting upon misinformation. It will also keep us from spreading potentially false and hurtful information.
“The naive believes everything, But the sensible man considers his steps.” (Proverbs 14:15 NASB 95)
Blessings,
Pastor Steven
[1] Constable’s Expository Notes, Proverbs.
[2] William MacDonald. Proverbs Devotional Commentary, pg. 185.